Return to CreateDebate.commrmountain • Join this debate community

Mr. Mountain's Community


Debate Info

18
27
Yes No
Debate Score:45
Arguments:26
Total Votes:50
Ended:12/19/09
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (12)
 
 No (14)

Debate Creator

bmountain(424) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Is torture ever justified? 6th

Yes

Side Score: 18
VS.

No

Side Score: 27
Winning Side!
3 points

Well first of all, it usually depends on what "tortured" your talking about. Sometimes it can be a good thing for somebody, because, a person can have a problem and can't stop, or control their problem. In order to help that person with his/her problems, sometimes torturing them can help. For example, if a Girl just can't stop texting and is a real addict,that it has been making her fail and get into trouble to many times, then maybe taking away her phone for a little bit and torturing her, making her angry inside, can actually help her later on in not being such an addict, and learn her lesson. Sometimes you just got to step it up and help somebody, even if you got to be mean and torture them.

Side: yes
1 point

Well-stated.this is one way of survival like that girl has to survive from trouble and achieve better at her failures without having that phone for texting.

Side: yes
2 points

Tortue is ok to use only if you need some kind of information from or something from somebody because for exmple torture should be used agiants the terrorists that are caught and dont whant to give you any information that could help you cath other terrorists that are hiding in America waiting to strike again at the right time and save many lives here in America.

Side: yes
2 points

Yes it is ok to torture some one if they deserve it. Dont just torture some one because you know you can. Like if some one decieved you: just dont talk to them o matter how sorry they say they are. Let them torture they shouldnt have never decieved you in the first place. Like chelesa said if your boyfriend cheats on you let him go. Just let him torture. Im saying if you deserve it you desreve. Some times people need torture to help push if your pushing them in the right place. Then its ok to torture them.

Side: yes
1 point

Well the some people say, treat people the way you want to be treated. No. You treat people the way they treat you. Because obviously thats how they want to be treated. So if someone is torturing you, its okay to torture them.

Side: yes
tr3rr3llj(11) Disputed
1 point

Sure they say revenge is a best dish served cold, but why would you want to do that? Think about the future. You're only wasting valuble time on conjuring a plot or scheme against that person, causing you to miss out significant matters in your life. And doing that could send you to the Grim Reaper's door early.

Side: No
1 point

Torture can be justified in some cases. If someone hurts a friend or family member, you have to make them realize what they have done. If you don't then that person will keep on doing it. If your girlfriend or boyfriend cheats on you and you choose to stay with them, then make them suffer! They deserve it for what they did to you. No to the point to where they end it, but to the point where they realize that they did wrong.

Side: yes
1 point

Sometimes torture is ok, also depending on how you see "torture". Avoiding a close friend or family member is a good way of torture. Torture can be good but it can also be bad. Physical torture is a not good way of torturing.

Side: yes
1 point

You know that saying,"violence is never the answer"? Forget it. There are certain situations, a select few, that call for a violent solution (most of them start with violence done unto you). In a perfect world the violence and torture would be unnecessary to obtain vital information or save a civilization. Unfortunately, in this reality, pain is the one thing that can get you almost anything so why not use it to your advantage?

Side: yes
1 point

It depends, it's not rely ok to tourture someone unless it's necesary like if you want to get some information out of the person and the person doesn't want to say nothing then that would be ok as long as nobody gets killed.

Side: yes
1 point

It is never ok to torture a man, but if the man deserves it then that might be the only way to teach him. I would never kill, those are not nice suggestions. We all must know the differnece betweeen good and evil men. If a man deserves to be either totured or killed then yes he should get it.

Side: yes
0 points

torture is baneful and a form of being altruistic.To some people torture is love,passion a form of revereness.To me torture is one way to live a life.It`s a way of survival.With it one is able to conquere conqestand tackle hardships in every way.There are those who torture for hurting:evil but in itself of life from no personative figure torture is justicified for being a survival truth.

Side: yes
3 points

There is horrid things that go round and round on this earth. Torture wouldn't alleviate any of it. Mahatma Gandhi once said an eye for an eye makes the world go blind, and making a criminal suffer wouldn't give justice. They would only feel slight regret because they would be feeling immense pain...but it wouldn't make them truly apologetic for their wrongs. I believe there is far better ways in this day and age to serve justice than harming someones health.

Side: No
3 points

Torture is not good, if you were to torture someone that would make you a really bad person. And just think about it you torture some one now but what goes around comes around. sooner or later somethng similar in pain will happen to the person that tortures the victim.

Side: No
2 points

No. If you were that person that was getting tortured, would you like to get tortured? I know I wouldn't want to .

Side: No
2 points

Torute is cruel and unusual punishment that is never necessary, I understand that people do bad things that should never go unsolved, but don't acquiesce to the abominable effects or ways of torture. It may have everlasting, inadequate, effects on a person.

Side: No
2 points

I do not think that torture is justified, because there are other forms of punishment and forms to get your point across. For example, when you are mad at someone, you do not have to torture someone by ignoring them or some other torture, you can instead talk it out with them. Torture doesn't have to be the solution to a problem.

Side: No
artanaya91(4) Disputed
1 point

i agree and disagree with you and the reason that i agree with you is because there are many other ways to set youre point across than torturing someone in order to obtain something but on the other hand some of those other forms will not work no matter how much you use them or how well you use these ohter forms againts them will not work because maybe somebody might have used one of the diffrent forms from tortue and they are aklready used to one of those forms

Side: yes
2 points

Torture to me is an unhumane and savage way to punish a persons wrong doing. Torture to me is more like revenge than a punishment. Torturing someone could be just as bad or worse than that persons wrong doing. You get on the same level as the criminal so you are both in my eyes considered criminals. There are other ways to punish someone and it gives them the same message.

Side: No
2 points

Torture is a very cruel unacceptable punishment. It doesn't matter if you hate that persons living guts you should never treat anyone like that. You treat others as you would want to be treated.

Side: No
2 points

To torture someone is to do something incredibly horrible to another person. "You can chain me, you can torture me, you can even destroy this body, but you will never imprison my mind" said Gandhi which I believe is ture. Just because you can torture someone doesn't mean that the ends justify the means. Torturing people doesn't really give someone justification to hurt a person.

Side: No
2 points

I do not think that torture is justified because, you should never want to intentionally hurt someone. To me when you torture someone your just being cruel and heartless. If you can torture someone than you should be able to be tortured back.

Side: No
1 point

In simple words torture is slavery. Chaining or holding someone down or on to something against their own will is wrong. Reason being is how would you feel if that was you being beaten and bruised just for an answer? I see no reason why someone should be mutilated till they're on verge of death. It is insanely and inhumanely injust.

Side: No
1 point

We are all human beings and we should treat each other like that. For example the Bush administration faced alot of heat on the issue of water-boarding of "alleged" terror suspects. No matter what they've done or what they're suspected of doing because in the end we're all human.

Side: No
1 point

Well in some cases I would have to say yes but it also depends on what type of torture. I mean lets just say some one murdered your whole family and didnt go to jail for some odd reason that the court wont explain, wouldnt you want them to suffer the way your family did? Of corse you would who wouldn't cause by no means should the crime go unjust but that would really just make you no diffrent from them just think of how devastated an hurt you and the rest of your loved one's were. No one should feel that pain

Side: No
1 point

It is common saying "Treat poeple how you wanted to be treated," but it is a double standard really. The role of the bigger person has to come in some where. If a person disrespected you, then most people would say be disrespectful back, but someone always has to be the nice bigger person. In the since torture is a double standard as well, it can be justified if a person murders your family and they should suffer in prison, but if a person didnt hurt anyone physically they shouldn't be harmed physically. Emotional torure though can be justified because the person that hurt you should know how you feel if they hurt you on purpose. People can be vindictive and self-obsorbed, so sometimes yes it okay but physical torture is not okay. Yes the terriost thing is a good point but physical torture is never a right way to handle things.

Side: No