I disagree because the people who do their work are going to continue to get good grades and be successful. So why intentionally punish someone for not doing their work when there going to continue to do the same thing

it all comes down to the student if they choose to not do anything about there grades and just want to fail let them fail. If they dont want to be successful in middle school what makes you think there going to care in high school or college where there are double the distractions.