Return to CreateDebate.commrmountain • Join this debate community

Mr. Mountain's Community


Debate Info

54
175
Yes No
Debate Score:229
Arguments:64
Total Votes:313
Ended:02/26/14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (18)
 
 No (44)

Debate Creator

bmountain(423) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Should students be forced to attend ASI for not completing an assignment (5th Period)

Yes

Side Score: 54
VS.

No

Side Score: 175
Winning Side!
3 points

I believe they should because if you are not responsible than you should be punished. If you accidently miss one question then you shouldn't go to ASI. If you guess then you should also go to tutorials and more ASI's so you can learn more.

Side: Yes
jake_CLUTCH2(8) Disputed
7 points

if someone doesn't know and doesn't want to learn it whats going to make them learn it the second time.

Side: No
Isabelle_18(10) Disputed
4 points

That's too much of our lives that could be spender with friends and family!!!!!

Side: No
wes_wescoast(3) Disputed
2 points

That's why you do it the first time. If you don't know it you should study more so you don't have ASI.

Side: Yes
bigE_CLUTCH3 Disputed
1 point

Missing ONE paper is not that big of a deal, like most people honestly forget about papers,i know i have

Side: No

You can only have so many second chances to do right and if u dont do it the 1st time what makes you think its gonna be different the second time....smh

Side: Yes
0 points

I agree, if you don't do one the first time and then say "ill get it next time" it becomes easier and easier to do so

Side: Yes
Kaydi_4412(3) Disputed
0 points

I support you on this, but what if a very good student skip one question because she or he has a hard time on question. So since they didn't finish they have to have ASI.

Side: No
caitlin_rose(2) Disputed
0 points

well like if u dont understand it then like u dont need it have a asi for missing it bc u didn't understand it

Side: No
1 point

At the start of the year the school should give a couple of breaks for you, but i think you should be able to get into a routine that will make you keep up with your homework.

Side: Yes
Hunter_A Disputed
1 point

well people that don't really care about school should not be forced to stay after school think about it they really don't care

Side: No
alycia_14(2) Disputed
1 point

Not everyone has a every day routine. Some people don't have a whole lot of time to spend with other people like family.

Side: No
1 point

yes because we didn't do or work that we had to do because is our responsibility

Side: Yes
0 points

I think students should have to attend these because doing our homework should be a routine

Side: Yes
robbie_schul Disputed
2 points

i agree it should be part of there routine but if you forget once then there should be a alternative option for people that can't stay after because peoples parents have jobs.

Side: No
Haley_18(6) Disputed
1 point

If a student chooses not to do it the first time then they are most likely not going to do their best the second time, they should get punished and not get a second chance.

Side: No
ZaCh_SaSfAi Disputed
-1 points

no shane you are wrong.and i am right.no its not a routine.

Side: No
-1 points

yes because they may not know what your dealing with outside of school you can get ASI if you had more then one chance tho

Side: Yes
13 points

I think that it is wrong to keep students after school for a hour and thirty minutes after we are already here for 7 hours a day. I spend more time with teachers and other students at school then I do with my family at home. That is before the ASI too. Im also involved in after school sports like track , cross-country ,football and tennis so it would be taking my time that I have for them.

Side: No
GMAN_CLUTCH1(3) Clarified
7 points

Also i could see the point of staying after school if you don't finish but i think once you finish you should be able to leave

Side: Yes
jake_CLUTCH2(8) Disputed
2 points

do u feel like cross country are more important then school work

Side: Yes
10 points

I think you shouldn't have too just give them a zero on the assignment. Then there grade in the class will look bad. they can go to a class during centime and work on it not stay an hour after school people have things to do and were already at school for 7 or 8 hours.

Side: No
9 points

No….1 hour and a half out of our lives that can be spent with our family, teachers are making us stay 1.5 hours more to a 7 hour school day. We should be able to spend most of our lives with our family instead of teachers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: No
Shane__(3) Disputed
2 points

I think you should be able to take 15-30 minutes a day to do homework and ASI is a reason to do so.

Side: Yes
Isabelle_18(10) Disputed
2 points

You can do homework at home! Thats why its called HOMEwork

Side: No
1 point

the statement is really off the top! i agree that we waste our times having 1 1/2 hours of extra school

Side: No
7 points

Students should not be put in ASI for missing one page of work. If the student repeats this behavior to the point where it is affecting their academic career in a bad way. Then they should be put in. One paper is not probable cause for such actions

Side: No
6 points

injustice for this malarky! people deserve respect and a second chance!

Side: No
8 points

I agree ,people mess up sometimes and everybody should get a second chance

Side: No
Shane__(3) Disputed
1 point

Yes a second chance not a third and a fourth and so on. The people who often get ASI get it over and over again

Side: Yes
6 points

I think students should not have to be forced to go to after school intervention ASI because. Kids that don't care about school or doing homework should be left to fail because they don't care and the people who run the ASI are honestly wasting their time with kids that don't care and if someone makes a bad grade honestly it could be both ways. They either just don't get it or don't care about the subject

Side: No
6 points

Students should not be forced to go to ASI because homework is the kids own responsibility. It is the students job to complete their assignment and if they don't want to do it then they can earn a zero. Giving kids a punishment is jus going to make them cheat and find other ways not to do it. Their punishment cant be failing their class and they will learn their lesson later.

Side: No
5 points

No, I think that if a student chooses not to do an assignment, then they should get punished for it by getting a 0 and not get another chance. Students make their own decisions and need to learn from them. Students ned to learn to be responsible and they won't learn if they keep getting second chances.

Side: No
Lawton28M(1) Disputed
1 point

well do you ever think that some people have other things to do when the day is over like some people have after school activities im taking time off of mma cause i hav so much homework

Side: No
5 points

My old school had a better program where during cain time we would be forced to go to a room and

do what we didn't finish they would go again until you got it done. this is good because people like me can't always stay after my mom needs a week in advance and that air school doesn't do that.

Side: No
5 points

No, just because someone didn't do their homework i don't think they should have to serve ASI. It is important to do your homework because it is important to get good grades in school, but sometimes people cant do their homework. Maybe that person had something going on that night like a basketball game well that student has invested a lot of time and effort in basketball they cant be expected to just not play and just do their homework. Sometimes you may have an event or something you have to do! You cannot be expected to always do your homework it is ultimately your responsibility but lets say you don't want to do your homework, well then thats your choice. You should be able to at least have a choice right?

Side: No
Amanda_LOLOL(10) Disputed
2 points

true, but which is more important basketball or your education which 1 seems to be more important?? i mean you cant be stupid person and play basketball thats just common sense.

Side: Yes
Brandon_R3(2) Clarified
1 point

i know education is more important to me but some people prefer other things :/

Side: Yes
5 points

I think students shouldn't have to go to ASI, If they didn't finish a paper. I think this, because a student be able to skip a question on a paper and not get in trouble. This should be able to happen. Now if the student is skipping a lot of questions each and very day, then ASI should come in.

Side: No
5 points

i dont think they should because if u think about it some kids get sent to it because they don't do one of the questions thats not right... and plus who the heck wants to stay after school for an hour people have lives you know... like were kids let us have fun don't keep us in school for an hour like c'mon is not ok i mean its ok if you get it if u just flat out don't do it but i think if u don't complete it like you don't understand it then they shouldn't give you it

Side: No
4 points

you can miss one question bye accident and be punished for it.

Side: No
wes_wescoast(3) Disputed
4 points

You should check your work and make sure everything is perfect because later it can hurt you when you are older.

Side: Yes
cj_CJ(5) Disputed
2 points

you are totally wrong!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:( >:P >:P >:P >:P >:P >:P

Side: Yes
Amanda_LOLOL(10) Disputed
2 points

im not wrong because you have to know how to count and how to do other things in order to be a hooper i would know i play basketball

Side: No
Amanda_LOLOL(10) Disputed
2 points

you may be punished but u deserve it if u didnt do it the 1st time after being told and and u have a due date then u should know your responsibilities and when those responibilities should take action.

Side: Yes
cj_CJ(5) Disputed
1 point

no i disagree with the statement because asi is for suckers who don't know how awesome life is

Side: Yes

well these "suckers" can gradually get better by going to asi for tutoring and sitting to think about the things that make them as u so ellequintly put it"suckers"

Side: Yes
4 points

i think that you shouldnt go to asi or detention if you forget your homework or didnt get cuase it was your fault so you should just get the grade that you deserve.

Side: No
4 points

Students shouldn't have to go to ASI just for not doing a little assignment. If they don't want to do their work then that's their problem. I honestly think teachers should just put in a 0 for the missing assignment. All teachers care about is getting good grades. They never think about the students' lives outside of school. Some kids have a lot of after school activities to do and might forget about homework. Other kids might have a lot on their plate dealing with family issues, so those kids could have more important things on their mind rather than remembering to do homework. It also gets super overwhelming when teachers pile on homework, so students get stressed out about getting it all done. When this happens, we forget about some homework we were suppose to do. There are a lot of reasons that students have for not completing their homework. Although some kids deliberately don't do their homework. This is why I believe students should not have to go to ASI when they don't complete an assignment.

Side: No
Amanda_LOLOL(10) Disputed
1 point

1st of all theres no such thing as a little assignment because these little assignment mean alot more to your grades.

Side: Yes
3 points

asi is too long and people have lives.i have been to asi and it sucks to be late to practice and after school activities.

Side: No
1 point

You are Right Zach!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Side: No
3 points

No, because I think that if you do most of the homework that you should not be punished by going to ASI for an hour and a half for something that is mostly completed.

Side: No
3 points

noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

Side: No
3 points

Students should't get sent to ASI for not doing a assignment. Some student don't care if they get sent to ASI.Some teachers don't even take a grade for that paper and they send people to ASI.People deserve second chances.

Side: No
3 points

I dont think thaw we should have ASI because we didn't finish a paper. I feel like a caintime is a better punishment, because then we get the help that we need and we don't have to stay after school because no one wants to do that. We don't want to stay after school we have life's too. We get busy and don't always have time to finish the home work you give us.

Side: No
2 points

It shouldn't be like that because as you get older, teachers will pile more and more homework on you, especially if you are in pre ap classes, and sometimes teachers will give you so much that you just can't get it all done, I should know because it has happened to me numerous times.

Side: No
2 points

no asi is too long an 1hr and 30mins.i think that they shouldnt have asi monday thru thursday is too much.

Side: No
2 points

its not fair. who wants to sit in a room no talking for a hour and a half we are only kids

Side: No
2 points

fgergtrffcbefcd78gyeugxg8d78xgjfg79xfgq76gfx9kf77x8g78ehdz89

Side: No
2 points

i think that you shouldnt go to detention if you just failed your homework cause whats the point of failing your homework and then do it again and just failing it again theirs just no point.

Side: No
1 point

asi is boring and should not be here i don't like it there is no point people should get a zero if they don't do the paper

Side: No
1 point

Yes/no but i have to go more with no. An hour and a half is way to long, we should only have to go for that assignment and just go. Honestly i feel like teachers have no respect for students , we have things to do after school. Thats why we're here for 7 hours. If students don't do the assignment , then thats their fault. They shouldnt have a second chance.

Side: No
-3 points