Return to CreateDebate.commrmountain • Join this debate community

Mr. Mountain's Community


Debate Info

24
22
Yes No
Debate Score:46
Arguments:24
Total Votes:58
Ended:12/18/09
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (15)
 
 No (9)

Debate Creator

bmountain(424) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Should students be able to attend the high school of their choice? 2nd

Yes

Side Score: 24
Winning Side!
VS.

No

Side Score: 22
4 points

If students (or their parents) are willing to commute to and from a school outside of their district, then the school should not be able to prevent them from attending. However, a restriction should be placed on the number of out of district students admitted to inhibit abnormal growth of one school or debilitating diminution of another. This will allow students desirous of features in a school outside of their district to enjoy these features, but only on a first come, first serve basis.

Side: yes
3 points

Yes, with the proper prerequisites. What I mean is this: Should a student with high marks but bad conduct attend one of the better public high schools in America? Yes. Should a student with low marks and excellent conduct be admitted? No. The reason is simple: when people want to go to a certain high school, it is either due to Academic advancement, or they want to go there simply because it is popular. Behavior is not so much looked at as academics are. No employer is going to fire you because you got a C in citizenship your junior year. Some go to school to learn, others go simply because they need social interaction. Students should have to earn their way into a school, with the measures of intelligence, not popularity or economics.

Side: yes
2 points

High school can be one of the best years of your life or it can be one of the worst. Reasons as to why it would be the best is if you were able to attend the high school of your choice. You would be in a comfortable environment where you enjoy the company there. It could be the worst if you aren't able to attend the high school of your choice and don't enjoy being at that particular school. Students should be allowed to attend the high school of their choice for this main reason. For example, I enjoy my high school but I would prefer to be at Booker T. Washington. If this were to happen, there might be a change in the amount students in a certain school. Some schools might have more students than others. Limits can be put on the amount of students that are accepted into the schools. It would be fair and would keep things balanced. The majority of the students would still be allowed to go to the high school of their choice.

Side: yes
2 points

Students, in my opinion, should be able to chose where they want to spend their high school years. High school is supposed to be the best four years of a teenagers life, and by allowing them to attend the high school they desire, they have a better chance to be successful. If students were able to attend the high school of their choice, they would chose the school based on its academy success, fine arts classes, a better community of people, or even better lunches. Students should have the choice to attend a high school that would get them ready for College and most important for life.

Side: yes
2 points

If students want to pursue their educational success or dreams through a certain school, they should be able to. Some students could feel as if the school they attend is dragging them down in their personal desires if what they want to move forward in is placed in a mediocre state. While colleges guide you toward your career, if students could choose the school that will push them closer to what they want in high school, they could change dreams to reality.

Many students have the same interests and so it is a possibility that a large portion of the population would attend one school. However, the local government could invest more into that particular school. Not to say that the other schools would eventually crumble due to lack of attention, but rather that the more appealing school could receive more to compensate for its large numbers. Students can achieve more by attending the high school of their choice.

Side: yes
1 point

I believe that students should be allowed to attend the high school of their choice purely based on the fact that if they want to go to a certain high school with specialties and such that they should be allowed. The district is divided up into sections. If you live in a certain section, you go to a certain school. This is beneficent both for the school and for the student. For the school, it is divided evenly among all the high schools and for the students because it is supposed to be the one closest to your house.

If you have the desire to go to a specialty school because you want to major in a specialty that they provide, then, by all means, go.

But if you have the desire to go just because you can, then there really is no point. You would be depriving another student the privilage of going just because you can do that?

Side: yes
1 point

Students definitely have the right to go to any public they want. The transfer system should still be in place, but students shouldn't have to renew it every year and hope they're accepted. Students may move to a different part of town, placing them in another school zone, but the friendships they've made don't disappear. It would be somewhat cruel to keep those few kids from seeing their friends on a day to day basis. The truth is that only a small percentage of students apply for transfers, and even less get them. Students will not be transfering schools wildly and randomly because most, those who don't move and whose houses are in the correct school zone, will want to go to a school with the friends they've known since elementary and middle school.

Side: yes
1 point

The future is filled with choices and one way to prepare the student for that type of future is by permitting them to choose the school they with to attend. If a student was able to pick the high school, then they would be albe to pick one that fits them the best. If the student is more athletic then they could go to a school that focuses more on athletic. If the student is more into getting a high education then they could go to one that focuses on high level classes, and so. The delema with this is that a large number of people might want to go to the same school, which would cause that school to become overpopulated. The school then could become like Harvard in the sense that only the best are accepts. If this were to happen then students would strive to work harder which could benefit the school district in overall.

Side: yes
1 point

My family and I change home, or move apartment every single year, and the one thing that I apreciate about my mom is that she permits my brother and me to attend at the school we want to. She does that for one exact reason. She believes that education is everything and she simply does not want us to give up school because we don't like or feel confortable with the school we are attending. Every single student should have the right to say which school they wish to attend. You would say that a student would not like to change school because of their friends and even though that is extreamly true, I believe we also care about our selves and we want to feel confortable with our enviroment. Wouldn't you as adults like to work where you wanted?

Side: yes
1 point

I do think that students should be able to attend the high school of their choice. As long as that school isn't already too full and you are willing to drive a possibly longer distance then it should be a students choice if they want to do that. If the school of the students choice is better academically, athletically, musically, or theatrically then why shouldn't the student go to the best high school that offers the program that they are most interested in.

Side: yes
1 point

Students should have the opportunity to attend the highschool of their choice. There are various types of high schools that specialize in many different types of majors, sports, and that carry different academic levels. If a student wanted to become better at a certain subject or major then the student should be able to choose and have the opportunity to attend the high school. Although the distance may be far if the student is determinded to attend then they would arrive at school at time.

Side: yes
1 point

Students should be allowed to choose the high school they want to go to as long as the school isn't already overcrowded. People can apply to any college they want, so why shouldn't they be able to apply for high schools?

In most cases, the feeling that you can succeed is derived from how supported and confident you feel where you are at the moment. If a student is in an environment that makes them feel supported and motivated to be sucessful, then they are more likely to be successful. If a student is forced to go to a school they don't like and feel uncomfortable in they could have conflict with other students, anger issues, and depression. Each student should have a chance to better themselves and work on a better future. The way you develop intellectually and socially throughout high school can affect you for the rest of your life, so why shouldn't students be able to go the high school that you feel will make your life better?

Side: yes
1 point

I believe that a student should be able to attend any school they want. I was suppose to go to Irving because of the district I live in, but I transfered because of the academics.Macarthur has better academics, and it was a better fit for me. If a student is okay with driving fifteen or thirty minutes to go to the school of their choice, then I believe it is okay and should be allowed.

Side: yes
0 points

Based upon my experience, I think that it should be decided by the students to whether which high school to go to. I myself live in the Nimitz district, and I decided to come to MacArthur because my friends were going there.

But with that in mind, my argument is a pretty one-sided point of view. Just because I decided to transfer to MacArthur doesn't mean that I should have. Again it all depends on what the student wants. I believe that they should have the freedom to choose where they want to get their public education. I mean, we get to choose what college we go to, why can't we choose which high school we want to go to?

Side: yes
-1 points

Not all high schools offer the same things. For example, Booker T. Washington in Dallas. This school mainly focuses on the performing arts. Perhaps a student plans to major in that specific area; attending that High School would be more beneficial. Some schools offer different courses or different variations on the same course such as language or musically related classes. Most students prefer a certain environment over another. These aren't the only cases.

Yes, overcrowding is a main issue. As long as the poplulation of students is controlled, I see no reason why students shouldn't be able to attend the school they choose. Certain limits can be set, but all in all, highschoolers should be given the oppurtunity to make the decision themselves.

Side: yes
3 points

If students could go to any high school they wanted, many schools would be too crowded. The schools that were not people first choices would be near empty and would not have as much money for fundings and supplies. The reason you go to the school in your district is so they can limit the amount of students. Not only that but if you want to go to the best high school and it happens to be an hour or 30 minutes away, you may often be late and then you couldn't get credit for your classes.

High school preference isn't like college, where many have one particular school they want to attend. And even then if its an hour or two states away, you live on campus or near it so there is no chance in you being late. College costs alot of money so it's understandable that you choose where you want to go, but high school is free of charge to get into and therefore don't get a choice.

Side: No
3 points

I think that if students were able to attend the school of their choice, all of the "elite" high schools would be filled up very quickly. Students would like to go to the rich, nice schools for either their academics or their sports programs. However, this would cause all of the "lesser" school to lose all of their academically and athletically gifted students. Plus, the commute to and from far away schools would be a hassle for other motorists that live in that area. Traffic would increase due to more people traveling to those schools.

Side: No
3 points

As much as we would all like to believe that all high school students are well rounded, intellectual, young adults, the fact of the matter is that were not. For this particular reason, letting high school students attend the high school of choice would be a highly insubordinate and regretful idea. Students would choose to attend the schools with all of their best buddies and failure to work and stay up to speed in schooling would result. Also, there would be a problem with overcrowded schools and undercrowded schools. Students would attend schools for reasons such as sports, academics, or friends, shooting down diversity in schools which most places of learning aim for. Cliches could also take over certain schools and before we know it outstanding MacArthur high school could be the new chill spot for MS-13.

Maybe if this was China, and morals were enforced more as a child, then choosing your own high school would not be a problem. But this is America, kids.

Side: No
2 points

Most students are indecisive, so if you give them an infinite amount of choices they wouldn't know what to choose and would probably end up making a bad decision. I think parents should have the major control over what school their children attend, but still take into consideration what the child wants. I know if I was given the opportunity to choose what high school I went to I would be going to Nimitz right now, but my mom made me go to MacArthur and I am glad she did. She obviously knew what was better and I didn't.

Another reason students shouldn't get to choose their high school is that one school may be a popular or a favorite school and it might become overcrowded while other schools will barely have any students. The system we have of splitting the city into different areas for each school is good for the purpose of equal schools.

Side: No
2 points

Students basically have a choice for what school they attend anyway, and there aren't any problems with it. For example, even though I live in Louisville district, I still go to school 30 minutes away in Irving. Most people just use fake addresses or transfers to be able to switch schools which will work as long as you get good grades and don't get into fights, which is fair since that's not the school you should be attending in the first place. If you mess up in a school you shouldn't be going to, you can't go there anymore, so it doesn't ever get too crowded.

Side: yes
2 points

With a crowd of people comes followers, and by that, I mean, if there is one huge student body attending MacArthur High School, then most of the students' friends and buddies will tag along, overcrowding the school and leaving little for the rest in the district. Given the decision to choose whatever school you like comes with consequences, like disorderliness in the school system, students' records being lost when transferred, or an uneven amount of students in a school to help the school stay thriving. Everyone tends to flock with the bigger crowd when our indecisive minds take over.

Side: No
2 points

Students wouldn't go to their assigned high school if they had to choose, they would like to go somewhere exciting, new, and fresh. It would be total chaos because there would be no organization in the school systems, especially with kids in their school that don't even live in the same city. If you want to go to a school that isn't in your city, then maybe you should move there, instead of driving up there everyday and coming back.

Side: No
1 point

The reason we have the system we have now is to keep everything organized and managable. If students were able to choose where they wanted to go, schools might be to overpopulated or to underpopulated. The conselors already have enough trouble trying to put kids in the classes they need to have to graduate. If you add 200 other kids to that, it makes things very difficult.

The way the schools districts are divided up the way they are to make getting to school as easy as possible. The father you have to drive, the harder it is.

If to many students were in one classroom, then learning could be a serious problem, and that is our entire purpose for going to school.

Side: No
-1 points

If students were allowed to choose which school they attended, the school populations wouldn't balance out. It would also be likely that people would seperate into groups, possibly by race, gender, popularity, style, or other ways in which students differ. I think the diversity in schools today make the discrimination of others less likely.

Side: No