Return to CreateDebate.commrmountain • Join this debate community

Mr. Mountain's Community


Debate Info

36
38
Yes No
Debate Score:74
Arguments:24
Total Votes:112
Ended:08/27/09
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes (13)
 
 No (11)

Debate Creator

bmountain(424) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Do schools kill creativity? (2nd period)

Yes

Side Score: 36
VS.

No

Side Score: 38
Winning Side!
4 points

I feel most schools require all students to be uniform. Yes, people have many opinions as to what they define as creativity. Maybe types of clothes or whether or not students are able to freely express through speech or literature. Most schools have a required dress code and have guidelines that prevent the students from saying what they may or may not truly feel. These aren't the only cases. Some may view this as organized, and that's okay. Everyone has their own view on the situation. Who's to say that anyone else with a different opinion is wrong or right?

Side: yes
4 points

I think schools do kill creativity because we as students each have our own personality, style and way of thinking. We do not have to wear uniform in high school but we have limits as to what can be worn, and in some cases what can be said. If a person wants to have twenty facial piercings or curse there will be consequences. I believe schools do kill creativity, not on purpose but, for the well being of the students.

Side: yes
3 points

Most classes, in enforcing structure and specific directions, smother students' individual takes and methods that often work better for the student and help them to learn. The originality of students is often guided into an 'allowed' form of originality, a mold, if you will, that defeats the purpose of creativity and when students leave school, they have been conditioned to do only certain original or creative things.

Side: yes
2 points

Sometimes you don't have a chance to make the work your own in school. They set up certain guidelines that you have to follow so it is hard to express your own ceative ideas when you have to stay inside the rules.

Side: yes
2 points

My answer is yes, I do believe schools kill creativity. Due to some bad seeds, school staff must lack trust in all the students at their school. Students are to dress in an appropriate manner, which is understandable and civilized. However, students have certain restrictions that seem unreasonable. For example, students cant have certain haircuts, hair colors, or piercings. For most teenagers, hair and jewelry, apperance in general is a very large and important part of youth expression. Also, students are denied their unalienable right to religion, and many other things they cant mention in school. For these reasons, I believe that schools do take away from creativity in some ways.

Side: yes
2 points

I believe they do because at school, instructors or principals limit to how students can express one's self, as in physicalness, or in other things they prefer. It seems as if they're kept in a box, with only the rules and regulations the schools enforce and accept to live with.

Side: No
2 points

In my opinion, school does kill creativity since many students want to be like their friends, to either become as popular as they are or to have the same attention as they do. By going to school, students are limited to their freedom since they can't express themselves and who they really are for being scared of what people might say about them.

Side: yes
1 point

Yes because school do limit a certain indivudals creativity, by telling them what they can and cannot do, say, wear and etc.

Side: yes
1 point

Yes because school do limit a certain indivudals creativity, by telling them what they can and cannot do, say, wear and etc.

Side: yes
1 point

Schools have all these rules about facial piercing, different colors hair, types of clothes, etc. I'm not sure on what the schools reason for these rules are, but i think ts because they few these things as weird or inappropriate. It shouldn't be up to them to decide whats appropriate or not on certain things. Most people make their hair rainbow or Peirce their eyebrow because thats how they express them selves and they want to be and individual. The schools try to make these things seem bad and try to make these kids conform to look they way they want them to.

Side: yes
1 point

I think that schools kill creativity because everybody seems to think that school is boring. Creativity is supposed to be fun and exciting. If school was more creative, more people would want to come and it would be more fun. However, that is not the case.

Side: yes
1 point

Schools do not completly kill creativity, but does limit it. When a student receives an assignment, they are usually given guidelines that do not always permit them to be as creative as they could possibly be. For instance, if a teacher tells a student to draw a picture in color that expresses them, but they are able to express themselves better by drawing in black and white, then their creativity will be limited. Some studens are also sometimes restricted in their writing creativity, by special formats that exist and by some of the topics that they have to write about. Creativity revolves around individuality, for it comes from what a person wants to do and not what everyone else is doing.

Side: yes
1 point

Schools kill creativity because of all the rules we are subject to follow. We might be able to choose our own clothing but our choices are strictly limited. Schools try to block out the truths of real life by making us follow rules that people in high positions force upon us. Our creativity is limited due to the view of our teachers, staff, and the district and what they believe we should learn and shouldnt learn. Our creativity is what makes us unique and without it we are nothing. When we are ask to draw and create a project, there are still rules based on what we are not allowed have in that project or drawing. Even in a creative class, we are still limited to what we say.

Side: yes
9 points

Though some of our freedoms are limited, such as our choice of clothing, we, as students, still have numerous other open opportunities to express our creativity, to be ourselves. The teachers and schools allow us to create our own artwork, posters, even murals, and if anything, our teachers encourage us to learn new innovations to making something even more creative. By coming to school, students have more chances to interact and incorporate their share of art than if they didn't go to school at all.

Side: No
7 points

School has no control over creativity in a person. Creativity is an individual characteristic. Despite restrictions on whatever work assigned, how the work is developed (both reatained in the student's mind and created in a physical representation) depends on how the student interprets the assignment. And even if the rules on a particular assignment are strict and exact, the way the student retains the information given and interprets their view of everything they learn is done very much in their own (creative) way.

Side: No
4 points

Schools do not "kill" creativity. They may supress it from time to time, but they don't kill it. On the contrary, students are expected to use creativity to improve assignments and show that they understand the assignments enough to modify them and prove mastery over a subject. Some students think the opposite of this, but that is just b/c the student is too lethargic or insipid to be able to be creative.

Side: No
4 points

I'd have to say no because whether we realize it or not, teachers are always trying to get it us to think and visualize things and encourage creativity. Creativity is something that the student has to put effort into, not something that the school or the teacher could kill. It all depends on whether the student wants to make something with his grades, his time, and his life. The fact of the matter is, schools do not kill creativity; the student has the choice to kill his/ her creativity.

Side: No
3 points

I think schools actually enhances your creativity because you are exposed to many different subjects and ideas. Different assignments in school stimulate your creativity and lets you practice it.

Side: No
2 points

I believe that certain classes in school don't give students any room for creative expression. There are a few classes that consist of long, boring bookwork, but if you take the right classes you can find teachers that appreciate and encourage creativity, and assign projects etc. that require imagination.

Side: No
2 points

No ,i don't believe that schools kill creativity.On some occasions schools can create creativity, .Teachers and students may inspire you in some way, which builds on your creativity.By being able to view other peoples apparences, showing their personality, showing you a new look, expanding on your creativity.

Side: yes
1 point

I think schools encourage creativity actually.

Teachers wouldn't normally like a person that doesn't think their own way as an individual.

Side: No
1 point

I think that it doesnt because each person gets to express their individuality. They get to dress how they want, act like they please, within reason, and get to play sports. What more could do to be creative?

Side: No
1 point

I think that schools dont kill creativity because each person gets to express their individuality. Students get to dress how they want, act like they please, within reason, and get to play sports.

I think of creativity as individuality. If a person is part of a team, each person brings something different and unique to the table.

Teachers apprciate individualism. I also agree with Kayleigh in saying that creativity is an individual's attribute which nobody can take away.

Creativity is defined as the ability to transcend traditional ideas, rules, patterns, relationships, or the like, and to create meaningful new ideas, forms, methods, interpretations, etc.; originality, progressiveness, or imagination, according to dictionary.com.

Based on how people look, fashion designers are considered creative because they create or created something that no one has ever thought of or done before.

At MacAthur, there are different classes for different people. There is sports management, art, english (for writing), speech, music classes, fasion design, ect.

Creativity and originatlity are two different things. Orginality is coming up with something on your own and creativity is when you take something and make it your own.

For example, in music, every musician has taken something from classical music. There is always something that starts a chain reaction. Without classical music, there wouldnt be the bands, or songs that bands created, today.

So does that mean that all the bands have no originality or does that mean that they just added some of their own pizzazz to the orgininal piece of work?

Side: No
1 point

I dont think school has control over a students creativity. They of course have rules and guidelines restricting certain clothing and facial peircings, but that is to have an appropriate appearance for school. Every student stilll has a wide berth to dress the way they want or to wear their hair a certain way. Sometimes the work teachers give us restrict creativity but never kill. We are still allowed to express ourselves through artwork, essays, etc.

Side: No